Keep it Like a Secret

Red Threads is presented by:

Attio is the AI CRM that keeps you ten steps ahead.

Ask Attio anything. Where should I focus? What deals are at risk? Search, update, and create across your customer data.

Ask more from CRM. Ask Attio.

Try Attio for free

"Obscurity is a far greater threat to authors and creative artists than piracy." — Tim O'Reilly

Almost every instinct to protect an idea is a bet about where the value lives. And a lot of us bet wrong.

Working inside the music industry for 20+ years, I’ve spent an enormous amount of time in the trenches of rights holder-related topics like copyright protection, and trademark and IP, and what is licensable and what is not.

Fun fact – there’s no copyright police and no patent police.

None of these protections are proactively enforced by agents roaming around, making sure everyone is following the rules.

They're civil matters, almost always addressed retroactively. One lawyer sues another, and the side with the most cash to burn and the most motivation usually wins, whether or not they're right.

So owning a patent, or a trademark, or a copyright protects nothing on its own. It buys you the option to spend time and money fighting for it later.

That's worth knowing before you treat these protections as bulletproof armor. They’re really a door to a fight, and you get to decide whether you want to walk through it.

We tend to believe the story about first movers. Get there first, plant the flag, win.

History doesn't really back it up.

Search engines existed before Google. Social networks existed before Facebook. Tablets existed before the iPad. Being first is a timestamp, and timestamps don’t really defend anything on their own.

The moat is whatever you build while your competitors are still in the conference room. Distribution. Trust. A direct line to your audience. A learning loop that tells you what to build next. Those accumulate into far more meaningful value. A filing date doesn't, (at least not on it’s own.)

This is where we landed with our team. The protection, if we pursue it, will mean far more in six months, after we've shipped and learned, than it does today as an abstraction.

The asset comes first. The fence comes after.

I’m willing to bet most of what you make isn't a patentable invention.

It's a digital product, a podcast episode, a framework, a post, a talk. For work like that, the danger is obscurity far more than theft. Almost no one is going to copy your episode, or your design, or your song. The real risk is that no one sees it, or hears it.

That was Tim O’Reilly’s position in his seminal 2002 essay about online distribution, and it's truer now than when he said it.

And yet the “keep it secret, keep it safe” instinct shows up anyway. You sit on your best idea because someone might take it. You save your sharpest thinking for the paid thing later. You hold back the good stuff.

Every one of those moves is a bet that your ideas are rare and need guarding.

They aren't. The version of your thinking that reaches the most people, gets quoted, gets argued with, gets built on, is the one that comes back to you as authority, trust, and the next opportunity.

Once you see it this way, the protect-and-defend toolkit gets simple.

Copyright already protects the exact words you publish, automatically, the moment they go live.

Trademark protects the name people use to find you, (so it helps to pick something distinctive over something generic.)

And patents are slow, expensive, and mostly a financing instrument/question for later…not a reason to slow your work down.

None of those tools, in and of themselves, make your work inherently valuable. The work does that.

We often treat our ideas as the scarce resource and our attention as the unlimited one. That’s perfectly backwards.

You’ll have more ideas in your lifetime than you'll ever ship. What you don't have is an unlimited supply of your best thinking. Every hour spent guarding an idea you haven't delivered yet, is an hour spent not building it.

A lot of builders pick the defensive posture early, often without noticing they picked it. They guard, they gate, they hold back, and they call it strategy. A lot of the time it's just the fear of “what will the others say if I share this work?”

You don't have to give everything away. Protection is a real tool, and sometimes it's the right one. But you don’t have to reach for it like a reflex.

Instead of asking "how do I protect this?" start asking "where does the value actually live?"

Chances are, it lives in what you'd build around the idea, in the trust and the distribution and the relationship with your customers or audience.

Guarding is a tax on your attention and critical thinking, when it’s done prematurely. The better move is to ship, learn, and let your work travel.

The fence can wait.

Use this to find the idea you've been guarding, and decide whether it's strategy or fear.

Here are other ways I can help:

And I’d appreciate your help:

Both make a real difference.

Thanks for spending time with Red Threads this week, I’m glad you’re here.

~ Jaime